A metal roof vs asphalt shingles is one of the most common comparisons Minnesota homeowners face when it’s time for a new roof. Both materials have clear strengths, but the right choice depends on your budget, your long-term goals, and how well each option holds up against harsh winters, heavy snowfall, and extreme weather conditions. Let’s take a closer look at how these two popular choices stack up for Minnesota homes.
How a Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles Handle Minnesota Weather
Minnesota is tough on roofs. Between snowy winters, freeze-thaw cycles, ice dams, high winds, and hot summers, your roofing material needs to perform year-round.
Metal Roofing in Severe Weather
Metal roofs are built to handle harsh weather conditions. Snow slides off more easily, which reduces the risk of ice dams and the heavy loads that cause structural stress. Metal roofing also offers superior wind resistance, with many products rated for winds exceeding 120 mph. That kind of durability matters when severe weather rolls through the Twin Cities and beyond.
Metal is also noncombustible, giving it a top fire rating. And because it resists cracking and warping through temperature swings, it’s an attractive option for homeowners who want a roof that performs in both extreme cold and summer heat.
Asphalt Shingles in Severe Weather
Asphalt shingle roofs are one of the most popular choices for residential roofs across the country, and for good reason. Modern architectural shingles offer solid wind resistance, and impact-resistant (IR) options can stand up to hail and storm damage. However, typical asphalt shingles are more vulnerable to freeze-thaw cycles over time. The organic mat beneath the surface can degrade, leading to curling, cracking, and the need for more frequent repairs.
With proper installation and regular maintenance, asphalt roofs hold up well. But in a climate as demanding as Minnesota’s, they simply wear faster than metal.
Lifespan: How Long Will Your Roof Last?
One of the biggest differences between these two materials is how long they last.
- Metal roofing: 40-70 years, depending on the type of metal and proper maintenance
- Asphalt shingles: Last 15-20 years on average, with premium options reaching 25-30 years
That longer lifespan is a major factor for homeowners weighing long-term costs. A metal roof may be the last roof you ever install, while an asphalt roof will likely need at least one full replacement during the same timeframe.
Learn more about how long roofs last here: How Long Do Roofs Last in Minnesota? A Material Type Guide
Cost Comparison: Upfront vs. Long-Term
Upfront Cost
There’s no getting around it: metal roofing comes with a higher initial cost. Metal roofing installation typically runs between $8-$14 per square foot, while asphalt shingles fall in the $4-$7 per square foot range. Installation costs are also higher for metal due to the specialized labor involved.
Long-Term Savings
When you look at the full picture, metal roofing often delivers better value in the long run. Here’s why:
- Fewer replacements: One metal roof can outlast two or three asphalt roofs.
- Lower maintenance: Metal requires less regular maintenance and fewer repairs over its lifetime.
- Energy savings: Metal reflects solar heat rather than absorbing it, helping keep your home cooler during the summer months and reducing energy bills. That energy efficiency adds up over decades.
- Insurance discounts: Some insurance companies offer lower premiums for metal roofs due to their durability and fire resistance.
For homeowners thinking about long-term investment rather than just the initial investment, metal roofing is often the best option.
Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles: Style and Curb Appeal
A common misconception is that metal roofs only come in a corrugated, industrial look. Today’s metal roofing materials are available in a variety of styles, including standing-seam metal roofs, metal roofing shingles, and steel shingles that replicate the look of traditional shingles, cedar shakes, or even wood shakes.
Asphalt shingles also offer plenty of aesthetic appeal. Architectural shingles provide depth and dimension that give your home a traditional look, and they come in a wide range of colors. For homeowners who want that classic appearance without a higher price tag, an asphalt roof remains a great choice.
Both options can boost resale value and curb appeal, so your decision may come down to whether you prefer a modern look or something more traditional.
Energy Efficiency and Environmental Impact
Metal roofing wins on both fronts. Its reflective surface reduces UV radiation absorption, which lowers cooling costs and helps keep your home comfortable without overworking your HVAC system. Paired with proper insulation, a metal roof can make a noticeable difference in energy bills.
Metal is also one of the most sustainable roofing materials available. Most metal roofs contain recycled content and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, contribute millions of tons of waste to landfills each year.
For Minnesota homeowners who care about environmental impact alongside performance, metal is the clear winner.
Which Is the Best Choice for Your Home?
There’s no single best roofing solution for every homeowner. The right roofing material depends on your specific needs, budget, and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Metal roofing may be the best option if you:
- Plan to stay in your home for a long time
- Want to minimize long-term costs and frequent repairs
- Prioritize energy efficiency and environmental impact
- Need maximum protection against severe weather and ice dams
Asphalt shingles may be the best option if you:
- Have a tighter upfront budget
- Prefer a traditional look with a variety of styles
- Are planning to sell in the near future and want solid curb appeal at a lower cost
Both are strong choices when paired with proper installation from a qualified roofing contractor. The key is making an informed decision based on various factors, not just the sticker price.
Learn more about the process of installing a new roof here: Installing a New Roof in Rogers, MN: Roof Replacement Guide
Get Expert Advice on the Best Materials for Your Minnesota Home
Choosing between different materials doesn’t have to be overwhelming. At 101 Roofing, we’ve been helping Minnesota homeowners make the right choice since 2005. As a GAF-certified contractor working with best materials from GAF, Malarkey, and EDCO, we’ll help you find the best roofing solution for your home and budget.
Ready to get started? Contact us today for a free consultation and free inspection. We’ll assess your roof, walk you through your options, and help you invest in a roof that protects your home for decades to come.
Related: What is the Best Roofing Material Investment for Rogers, MN Homeowners?
